How does one say "Up yours" in German?

Published on September 2 2005

German Callousness: Kicking Hurricane Victims While They're Down - International - SPIEGEL ONLINE - News
Hurricane Katrina has cost the lives of hundreds and devastated the US Gulf Coast. But instead of aid donations and sympathy, the Americans have heard little more than a haughty "I told you so" from Germany. It's another low point for trans-Atlantic relations -- and set off by a German minister. How pathetic. For the record: German Chancellor Gerhard Schröder offered his condolences to US President George W. Bush for the Hurricane Katrina disaster that has hit the Gulf Coast. Both he and his fellow Germans, Schröder wrote, feel "great sympathy for the fate of those people affected by the hurricane." Nice words to be sure, but that was it. No pledges of aid money, no announcements of immediate help -- although finally, two days later, the German interior minister did manage to come out with a hesitant offer of assistance. And let's be honest, the crisis region this time around isn't in the Third World, but is in the United States of America. There really isn't much of a need for German helpers -- experienced as they may be from aid missions from Kosovo to Afghanistan -- because the American authorities are already doing as much as can be done. Nevertheless, German aid money delivered to American aid agencies would surely be welcome on the other side of the Atlantic. But apparently, people over here believe that the Americans over there don't really need help. Strange. The same people who normally spend their time pointing their holier-than-thou fingers at the ghettos and slums in the US, the same ones who describe America as an out-of-control capitalist monster, are now, when the Americans could really use a bit of help, oddly quiet. Apparently the Americans had it coming: "The American president has closed his eyes to the economic and human damage that natural catastrophes such as Katrina -- in other words, disasters caused by a lack of climate protection measures -- can visit on his country." Who wrote this? None other than Jürgen Trittin, Germany's minister of the environment..... .....It's not the American people's fault that the storm hit and they couldn't have stopped it. The Germans, on the other hand, could have done a lot to prevent World War II. And yet, care packages still rained down from US troops. Trittin's know-it-all stance is therefore not only tasteless, it is also historically blind.

Written by admin

Published on #Current Affairs

Repost0
To be informed of the latest articles, subscribe:
Comment on this post
A
I agree, blaming Bush does not help right now. The city government screwed up as well.<br /> <br /> And yes, there is not only sympathy and donations in Germany, but also some malicious joy, which I covered here as well: <br /> http://atlanticreview.org/archives/124-Commentaries-on-the-Katrina-disaster.html
Reply
M
Wow...linked through by the Post? I'm going to have to figure out how <em>that's</em> done. I wondered what the surge in hits was all about.<br /> <br /> <a href="http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/09/03/AR2005090301433.html">How Could This Be Happening in the United States?</a><br /> <br /> This is another article in today's post on the number of countries that have offered aid. It's wonderful to see these offers--I hope we have enough sense to take it. That doesn't mean I don't get upset at the "I told you so" and the "nyah, nyah, nyah" and the US-bashing I see from so much of the world's media.
Reply
M
Hi, I came to your blog through the link at the Washington Post website. I try to get reliable information about the situation.<br /> I'm very sorry for all the people going to this disaster - victims and people helping what they can.<br /> In Germany, yesterday, on TV was said that the Germans are giving more money to the German Red Cross and other organizations for helping in the USA, than they did for the victims of the flooding which damaged part of southern Germany some weeks ago.<br /> We still remember the help of the USA and I think because many of us came over to spend our vacations for example in New Orleans we can understand what is lost. And we care!
Reply
M
No, instead of saying Spiegel misquoted Tritten, you told me to check my facts. Assuming Spiegel quoted Tritten correctly, the man said Katrina is a disaster caused by the US' lack of climate protection measures. <br /> <br /> And yes, it was a very inappropriate comment, considering the body count is just beginning. I also think the the Spiegel remark about World War 2 was inappropriate as well, by the way.<br /> <br /> Germany has made an offer of help. Danke. Danke schon. Hopefully we will take it.<br /> <br /> Am I honestly content with the administration's handling of this? Of course not--the relief effort could/ should have begun before the hurricane even made landfall. But I'm also not in a position to judge the relief effort, and I certainly don't think "blame Bush" is going to make that effort any quicker.
Reply
A
Did I say that Spiegel misquoted Trittin? No, I did not!<br /> <br /> If you think "close his eyes" means "caused", that's your problem. <br /> <br /> If you want to beat on Trittin, have fun. Enjoy yourself. His comments were inappropriate indeed.<br /> <br /> All I said was that Spiegel is stupid, Schroeder offered immediate help rather than just sympathy. <br /> <br /> That offer of help was not fast enough? Well, Bush was not fast enough either. He cut funding for the levees, for the Amry Corps of Engineers. <br /> <br /> The National Guards supposed to guard the nation in cases of disasters, but too many National Guards and their equipment are in Iraq.<br /> <br /> Germany has offered the help, but so far the US has not accepted the help. They seeem to take their time. <br /> <br /> Honestly, are you content with the Bush administration handling of this?
Reply